A new Michigan State University project is bringing the landmark Beal Seed Experiment into the future, investigating how long seeds remain viable underground and exploring the persistence of biennial weeds.
Funded by AgBioResearch’s Douglas and Maria Bayer New Initiatives Fund for Sustainable Agriculture, the project builds on William James Beal’s pioneering seed-burial experiment, which began more than a century ago at MSU. Beal buried bottles of seeds and periodically recovered them to test whether they could still germinate, demonstrating the remarkable longevity of some seeds.
Led by Eric Patterson and Grace Fleming, the new initiative brings together researchers from the Department of Plant, Soil and Microbial Sciences, the Department of Horticulture, and the Department of Plant Biology, along with the MSU Herbarium. Collaborators include Erin Hill, Erin Burns, Bob Van Buren, Mason McNair, Lauren Sullivan, Lars Brudvig and Herbarium Director Dave Tank.
The team is preparing seeds from approximately 50 species, targeting 2,500 seeds per species. The updated protocol focuses on biennial species and includes additional weeds, such as ragweed, Johnsongrass and teasel. Researchers are conducting baseline germination tests and molecular analyses before burial. Unlike Beal’s original experiment, the project will also compare buried seeds with seeds stored dry under controlled herbarium conditions.
The initiative also connects historical research with hands-on education. Students in Patterson’s CSS326: Weed Science course are testing seeds from Beal’s original collection that failed to germinate in the first year, investigating whether they may still be viable or whether Beal buried dead seed.
Seed burial for this project is planned for late summer 2027, with the first recovery scheduled for fall 2032 and subsequent recoveries every five years.
“It’s very fun and interesting,” Fleming said of the project, which artfully combines Beal’s vision with a century of science and technology. “We just have to wait so long for results. But hopefully, 100 years from now, someone will learn something about these biennial species.”
Beal’s original experiment became a landmark in seed biology, demonstrating that buried seeds remain viable far longer than previously known. The new project follows his general approach to assembling seed bottles and burying them while refining the protocol with input from collaborators, including PSM weed scientist Erin Hill.
“This time our focus is biennial species,” Grace said. Some of the longest-lived seeds from Beal’s bottles were biennial, with the longest-lived, Verbascum blattaria, still surviving 141 years later. The researchers are also adding new species that were not considered weeds during Beal’s time, including ragweed, Johnsongrass and a thistle that is a particular favorite of Hill.
Grace is currently collecting seeds from approximately 50 species, with a target of about 2,500 seeds per species. Each burial bottle will contain 100 seeds, packed in silica sand. Before burial, the team is conducting germination tests and molecular analyses to establish a baseline for future comparisons — key controls that were left out or not possible during Beal’s initial experiment.
Seeds are being collected from Fleming’s own yard, from McNair’s property, the Agricultural Farm on campus, Corey Marsh, and anywhere weeds grow and the researchers have access. Hill has also contributed seeds for teasel (Dipsacus spp.), which simply was not a problem in Beal’s time.
The researchers are also introducing a control that Beal’s experiment did not include: some seeds will be stored dry in the herbarium. Modern climate control, which did not exist in Beal’s time, makes it possible to compare long-term burial with dry storage under controlled conditions.
Locating the burial is a practical challenge for the team. Circumstances have changed since the experiment began, and protecting the new seed collection while ensuring that future researchers can recover it requires careful planning.
More than a replication, the project provides opportunities to connect students with historical research and contemporary weed science.
This semester, students in Eric Patterson’s CSS326: Weed Science course are examining seeds from Beal’s original experiment that never germinated, testing whether any may still be viable. The course also incorporates seed burial and the eventual recovery and testing of buried material.
Hill is contributing weed seeds and germination protocols, while Grace Fleming will carry out the laboratory germination work. Bob Van Buren brings expertise in desiccation experiments, and Tank and Van Buren are also contributing to phylogenetic comparisons, examining relationships among weeds whose lineages include annual and biennial species. Outreach and extension activities are being designed through the 4-H Children’s Garden by McNair and the Schoolyard Ecology Project with Sullivan.
The bottles are still being prepared. Recoveries will take place at five-year intervals once burial occurs, with future committees making decisions about how the experiment should continue.
That means the earliest results will arrive years after the current team has completed much of its work — and the most revealing findings may belong to researchers who have not yet entered the field.
This story originally appeared on the College of Agriculture and Natural Resources website.