Sharia is a fundamental religious concept in Islam that has faced heavy scrutiny — both in the year leading up to the 2026 election and following the election of Muslim Americans to various political offices.
Asma Uddin is an assistant professor of law at Michigan State University’s College of Law, where her expertise includes religious liberty, constitutional theory and judicial rhetoric. Here, she explains Sharia and potential misunderstandings of how the teachings have been appropriated.
Muslims understand Sharia as divine guidance, but interpreting that guidance is a human endeavor. This process, known as “fiqh,” has produced a wide range of interpretations concerning how Muslims should pray, when to fast, what to eat, how much to give to charity, and how to approach marriage and divorce.
These interpretations vary across Muslim communities. Many Muslim-majority countries incorporate interpretations of Sharia into family law. In the United States and Europe, marriage and divorce are governed by civil law, though some Muslims also seek religious guidance or arbitration in these matters. Americans often think of law as something established and enforced by the state, but Sharia is broader than that. It encompasses religious and ethical obligations that Muslims may follow in their everyday lives, regardless of whether the state enforces them.
Sharia does not have independent governmental authority in the United States. Muslims can voluntarily follow religious teachings, and certain agreements informed by those teachings may be enforceable under ordinary American legal principles. Religious obligations, however, cannot override applicable American law.
In practice this often means two layers running side by side: a religious marriage ceremony alongside a civil marriage license, or a will shaped by religious priorities but bound by state inheritance rules. U.S. courts generally cannot resolve theological disputes, but they may enforce contracts and arbitration awards arising from religious arrangements when doing so is consistent with neutral legal principles and applicable law.
In much the same way, Muslims may consult religious scholars or mediators for guidance on family or financial disputes. These arrangements are generally voluntary, and any agreement meant to be legally binding must comply with American law. Like other religious communities in the country, Muslims may organize aspects of their personal lives around their faith, but they do so within the framework of American law.
Many states have taken different approaches with Sharia law, and their results have often turned on constitutional limits.
In an Islamic marriage contract, promising the wife a marriage gift is referred to as “mahr.” A court asked to enforce such an agreement does not decide what Islamic theology requires; it decides only whether it meets ordinary contract law. In 2020, a Maryland appeals court held that a “mahr” could be enforced only under the same secular standards as any agreement between spouses.
Between 2010 and 2012, lawmakers in at least 32 states introduced bills restricting courts’ consideration of foreign or religious law. Although many proposals did not mention Sharia explicitly, they emerged amid political campaigns against the perceived threat of Islamic law. In 2010, Oklahoma put a constitutional amendment barring courts from considering Sharia on the ballot. Voters approved it, but a federal appeals court upheld an injunction against it, finding that it violated the First Amendment’s protection of religious freedom and a federal judge struck it down permanently in 2013.
On a federal level, in June 2026, Rep. Keith Self of Texas introduced a bill barring federal courts from enforcing foreign or religious laws that conflict with the Constitution. But courts already refuse to enforce agreements that violate the Constitution or other applicable laws.
American law already provides safeguards against religious rules being imposed through the courts. Muslims, like members of other faiths, can organize their personal lives around their religious beliefs.
Sharia informs the religious practices of Muslims around the world, while governments differ considerably in whether and how they incorporate interpretations of Islamic law into their legal systems. Concerns arise from how some governments enforce Islamic law. In Iran and Afghanistan, laws and policies sharply restrict women’s and girls’ rights. These policies raise serious questions about religious coercion, gender equality and freedom of conscience.
In other parts of the world, Muslim scholars and reformers have worked to advocate for equality and justice in Muslim family laws. Musawah is an international movement, founded in Malaysia in 2009, that argues Islamic teachings can support women’s rights and challenges discriminatory interpretations of religious law.
Ultimately, Americans tend to question whether Sharia itself is compatible with American law. That framing blurs an important line. A government forcing religious rules on unwilling citizens is not the same as a person choosing to follow them. A woman who wears a hijab is not asking the state to mandate religious dress.
Responses and excerpts are from an article published in The Conversation.