• Jump to Header
  • Jump to Main Content
  • Jump to Footer
Michigan State University
Michigan State University
MSUToday
  • For Media
  • Experts
  • Releases and Statements
  • Sign Up
  • Update Information
MSUTODAY
  • Browse Stories By

    Topics

    Explore stories by subject area

    • Arts and Culture
    • Business and Economy
    • Climate and Environment
    • Education and Learning
    • Engineering, Science and Technology
    • Government and Society
    • Health and Medicine
    • Media and Communications
    • MSU Leadership and Impact
    • Sports and Recreation
    • Student and Campus Experience
    View All Stories

    Collections

    Curated story series

    • Alumni stories
    • Turfgrass
    • Ask the Expert
    • Big Ideas
    • Climate solutions
    • Water at MSU
    • Mobility
    • Spartan Perspectives
    • Student views
    • Graduate voices
    • Faculty voices
    View All Collections

    Featured

    Editor's picks

    • MSU earns top 100 ranking by Times Higher Education

      Oct. 12, 2026

      MSU earns top 100 ranking by Times Higher Education

    • New spaces, new opportunities at MSU 

      Oct. 14, 2026

      New spaces, new opportunities at MSU 

MSUTODAY
  • Browse Stories By

< Browse Stories By

Topics

Explore stories by subject area

  • Arts and Culture
  • Business and Economy
  • Climate and Environment
  • Education and Learning
  • Engineering, Science and Technology
  • Government and Society
  • Health and Medicine
  • Media and Communications
  • MSU Leadership and Impact
  • Sports and Recreation
  • Student and Campus Experience
  • View All Stories

Collections

Curated story series

  • Alumni stories
  • Turfgrass
  • Ask the Expert
  • Big Ideas
  • Climate solutions
  • Water at MSU
  • Mobility
  • Spartan Perspectives
  • Student views
  • Graduate voices
  • Faculty voices
  • View All Collections

Featured

Editor's picks

  • MSU earns top 100 ranking by Times Higher Education

    Oct. 12, 2026

    MSU earns top 100 ranking by Times Higher Education

  • New spaces, new opportunities at MSU 

    Oct. 14, 2026

    New spaces, new opportunities at MSU 

  • For Media
  • Experts
  • Releases and Statements
  • Sign Up
  • Update Information
Advertising

March 11, 2026 | Read time 7 min

SHARE

Anti-counterfeit warnings can backfire, MSU report finds

By: E LaClear, Alex Tekip

Summary

  • A new report from Michigan State University finds that anti-counterfeiting messages can backfire when consumers feel their freedom to choose is threatened — a reaction known as psychological reactance.
  • Researchers from MSU’s Center for Anti-Counterfeiting and Product Protection reviewed 94 campaigns and found many rely heavily on fear-based tactics that may reduce effectiveness.
  • Counterfeit goods remain a major global issue, with a market estimated at $467 billion and most consumers reporting they’ve bought fake products knowingly or unknowingly.
  • MSU researchers say campaigns may work better when they move beyond fear and focus on persuasive, constructive strategies that guide consumers toward better choices.

Imagine you’re scrolling through an online marketplace and spot a pair of designer shoes you’ve been longing for priced far below retail. A warning pops up, alerting you of the dangers of buying counterfeit goods. Feeling talked down to, you dismiss the message and click “Buy now” anyway, figuring it’s just a scare tactic.

A new report from Michigan State University shows that anti-counterfeiting messages can backfire if people feel their freedom to choose a product is being threatened. When that happens, they often tune out the message, and efforts to change their buying habits don’t work.

This concept, called psychological reactance, is introduced in a new report conducted by researchers in MSU’s Center for Anti-Counterfeiting and Product Protection, or A-CAPP, titled “When Organizations Talk to Consumers about Counterfeiting.” It occurs when consumers develop unintended negative feelings, thoughts and behaviors upon exposure to anti-counterfeiting messages.

Person outdoors wearing a light-colored top and a gray-and-white striped cardigan, standing in front of greenery.
Anastasia Kononova, associate professor of advertising and public relations at MSU.

“When consumers view anti-counterfeiting messages that use controlling language, focus on negativity or loss, and include graphic content, they may feel threatened by the perceived limitation in their choice of vendor,” said Anastasia Kononova, associate professor of advertising and public relations in the MSU College of Communication Arts and Sciences and a lead researcher on the report.

Kononova and the A-CAPP research team reviewed 94 campaigns with nearly 400 unique messages and conducted experimental testing to help clarify messaging nuance in the fight against fake products. According to the researchers’ findings, organizations from the pharmaceutical, electronics and tools industries used the most reactance-inducing elements in their messaging.

The global counterfeits industry is estimated to be worth $467 billion. It can mean problems for consumers, from wasted money on low-quality items, to health consequences from hazardous materials used to create them. Previous research from MSU’s Center for Anti-Counterfeiting and Product Protection showed that 74% of consumers surveyed across 17 countries have purchased counterfeits knowingly and/or unknowingly. More than half of participants reported buying counterfeit products knowingly, while two-thirds reported having been deceived into buying these products.

“The exponential growth in the prevalence of counterfeit products makes it critical for multiple stakeholders to understand the need and value of communicating with consumers to change how they think about counterfeits and their own purchase decisions,” said Kari Kammel, director of the A-CAPP Center.

Moving past fear-based messaging

Ninety percent of messages in the new report contained at least one reactance-reducing feature, or message appeal that lowered the chances that audience members would feel threatened by them. Despite this prevalence, most of those reactance-reducing messages were limited use of low-controlling language, such as suggesting consumers not to buy counterfeits, and self-referencing, which relates the risk of counterfeiting to individuals’ personal experiences, instead of other strategies, such as:

  • Gain frames, or highlighting what one would gain from refraining to buy counterfeit
  • Narratives, or individual stories
  • Positive emotional appeals, or highlighting positive aspects of buying authentic brands

Though reactance-reducing features were frequent, reactance-inducing features were prevalent in more intense ways. These messaging strategies attempt to highlight the dangers of buying counterfeit products by emphasizing fear-based appeals, such as highlighting the health risks associated with buying and using counterfeits, referencing death, criminal activity and support for organized crime, and harm to society as a potential outcome of buying and using counterfeit products.

“The best way to influence consumers may be to send messages that aren’t solely fear-focused,” Kononova said. “Limiting messages to communicating about the dangers of buying counterfeits without persuading consumers how to change their attitudes and behaviors might not lead to the most optimal outcomes.”

Consider the source

Psychological reactance is just one aspect of anti-counterfeiting communication nuance. Participants in the report perceived nongovernmental organizations, or NGOs, as the least authoritative sources for anticounterfeiting messaging. Commercial companies, government agencies and international organizations all ranked higher.

Person in a dark blazer and a white lace top posing for a portrait against a dark background, with shoulder‑length wavy hair.
Kari Kammel, director of the MSU Center for Anti-Counterfeiting and Product Protection.

“Perceived authority factors heavily into how consumers interpret messages, especially when considered alongside psychological reactance,” said Kononova. “When fear is communicated by an authoritative source, consumers conflate the authoritative attributes of the source with a higher chance of trying to control them and limit their freedom. Eventually, they stop listening, and the attempt to change their attitudes and behaviors fails.”

Dynamics like these and other factors — message formats like print versus video; co-reactance messaging or messages that include both types of appeals that elicit and reduce reactance; audience member purchasing history; and other characteristics — each impact how individual consumers interpret and act upon anti-counterfeiting messages. They also open the door for partnership between different stakeholders to increase messaging effectiveness.

“The tricky part is informing consumers about the risks in a way that enhances the chances of their receptiveness to these communication efforts,” said Kammel. “No one likes to feel scared or like their freedom is being limited, so there’s a lot of nuance needed in anti-counterfeiting messaging — and that nuance changes depending on who and where the message comes from.”

Tips for safer shopping

The A-CAPP Center recommends these practices to consumers who want to ensure their products are genuine and safe:

  • Cut out the middleman. Buying directly from a brand or manufacturer is a safe way to avoid counterfeits. Visit the company’s website or call them directly to place your order.
  • Double-check distributors. If you buy from e-commerce sites working with third-party sellers like Amazon or Walmart, it’s a good idea to check who created the listing. Look for words like “sold by” on the product page. The safest listings come from a products manufacturer or brand.
  • Do your own research. Before you buy from a third-party seller, consider looking them up online first. If you have trouble finding a company website, physical address or other basic information, it may be wise to find a different seller.
  • Read reviews. While product reviews aren’t always reliable, a flood of negative reviews about the item’s quality or the seller’s customer service could indicate an untrustworthy seller.
  • Review and report. After buying from a third-party seller, thoroughly inspect your purchases. Are there typos on the label? Is the product logo different or altered in some way? If yes, it’s a good idea to avoid using the product. You can report the issue to the e-commerce platform where you purchased it and request a refund. You also could report the product listing to the actual brand or manufacturer. To help prevent other shoppers from making the same purchase, report the counterfeit seller to a government agency to investigate. For example, in Michigan, you can report counterfeit products to the state attorney general’s Consumer Protection team.

Tips for communications campaigns

Brand professionals and other stakeholders may reassess their voice, audience and tactics in designing future anti-counterfeiting communication campaigns. Here are some tips A-CAPP researchers recommend.

  • Know your audience. Add a consumer segmentation strategy to your campaign development. Counterfeit buyers are more confident that they can protect themselves, but they also respond well to anti-counterfeiting messaging that is tailored to their perceptions and past behaviors. They’re open to sharing these messages with others and express more understanding of the problem severity, their vulnerability and motivation to protect themselves.
  • Get the best of both worlds. Low-reactance messages may help increase awareness and online engagement, while high-reactance messages may help curb counterfeit buying behaviors. A sound strategy does not solely center on communicating about the dangers of buying counterfeits or the severe harms they can cause; rather, offer consumers specific ways in which they get motivated to buy authentic brands and also know how to spot fakes in a sophisticated environment where it is increasingly difficult to do so.
  • Tell the story. Low-reactance persuasion techniques like storytelling and gain-focused narratives are currently underutilized but can help increase the impact of messages. Using video instead of print can also maximize engagement and drive behavior change.
  • Stakeholders, unite! Draw from diverse expertise to make your messaging more persuasive. For example, if you’re a nonprofit, reach out to law enforcement and other government agencies for partnership — and vice versa.

MEDIA CONTACTS

Alex Tekip
AdvertisingMedia and CommunicationsMarketing and SalesBusiness and EconomyMSU ResearchMSU Leadership and Impact

MSUToday Weekly Update

The MSUToday Weekly Update email showcases how Spartans are making a difference through academic excellence, research impact and community outreach. Get inspired by these stories of innovation, collaboration and determination. Plus, enjoy photos and videos of campus and more MSU content to help keep you connected to the Spartan community.

Sign UpUpdate My Information

Connect With Us

Visit our Facebook pageVisit our page on XVisit our Instagram pageVisit our LinkedIn pageVisit our YouTube pageVisit our TikTok page

Resources

  • A to Z Index
  • Find People
  • Maps
  • Email
  • Student Information System (SIS)
  • D2L
  • Libraries
  • Tech Support
  • MSU Misconduct Hotline
  • Social Media Directory
  • Events Calendar
  • For Media

Health and Safety

  • MSU Police and Public Safety
  • Olin Health Center
  • Counseling & Psychiatric Services (CAPS)
  • University Health and Wellbeing
  • MSU Health Care
  • Civil Rights and Title IX
  • Our Commitment
  • Center for Survivors
  • Security & Fire Safety Report
  • University Policy on Relationship Violence and Sexual Misconduct
  • Notice of Non-Discrimination, Anti-Harassment and Non-Retaliation
  • Health Care Non-Discrimination Notice

Support Services

  • Disability Resources
  • Supportive Services
  • Learning Resources

Working at MSU

  • Human Resources
  • EBS Login
  • Job Postings
  • Employee Assistance Program

Reports

  • CARES Act Funding
  • Student Achievement and Outcomes

Contact us

517-355-1855

Address

Michigan State University
426 Auditorium Road
East Lansing, MI 48824

Follow Us

  • Visit our Facebook page
  • Visit our page on X
  • Visit our Instagram page
  • Visit our TikTok page
  • Visit our LinkedIn page
  • Visit our YouTube page

If you're having accessibility issues, please let us know.

Know More: Campus Safety Information and ResourcesTransparency Reporting: Budget & Salary/Compensation
  • Contact Information|
  • Site Map|
  • Privacy Statement|
  • Site Accessibility|
  • Call MSU: (517) 355-1855|
  • Visit: msu.edu|
  • Notice of Nondiscrimination|

SPARTANS WILL|© Michigan State University|

Latest News